What’s New?

We have just switched from our Winter inventory to our Spring and Summer! Stop in and check out our golf section with a "Build-Your-Own Set" option, baseball gear, kayaks, paddleboards, lifejackets, fishing gear, and everything in-between!

We are currently taking:

Baseball, Lacrosse, Water Sports, Roller Skates, Cleats, Football, Yard Games, and anything that has a spring or summer use!

We only accept clean and functional equipment

Our pre-owned gear is subject to a quality control specification, we don't just accept anything.

High Quality

Fully restored

Best prices

Fully staffed

About our company

Replays Sports Exchange has been in Evergreen since 2011. In June of 2017, our family purchased the store, and have been loving it since! We moved from the heart of Arkansas a little over two years ago and chose Evergreen as our home because of the sense of community and the beautiful scenery. Replays serves to the outdoor aspect of this beautiful state.

We are conveniently located right off of Evergreen Parkway, and we supply used sports equipment, including (but not limited to), hiking, camping, skiing, football, baseball, lacrosse, ice skating, snowboarding, golfing, and SO much more. We love to do what we can to make our neighbors happy, so if you have any questions, give us a call, shoot us an email, or stop on in!

Consignor Guidelines


  • Best value store I have ever seen.

    Daniel Dan ― Conifer, CO

  • What a great selection!

    Mark Wellbeck ― Morrison, CO

KristenSales Associate.

Mom to Oliver, Kristin enjoys spending her time cheering on the local sports teams and is an expert on our consignment process! If you have any questions or concerns that you need addressed, she is the lady for you!

KylynStore Manager.

Kylyn is a CU Boulder transfer student that enjoys being outdoors exploring the mountains (her favorite place in the world), and spending time with her fur-babies! Kylyn is well-rounded on most all inventory carried in the store, and is a wiz at the google machine. Have questions about what you need, or completely lost in general? Kylyn is there most days and LOVES helping out the neighbors!

RacheleSales Associate.

Rachele is a student at Metro State University and loves everything Hockey. GO AVS! Rachele is the best at helping our customers finding specific items and making sure that your experience is as quick and painless as possible. Don’t want to root around for hours looking for things? Put Rachele up to the task and she’ll get you in and out before the headache even sets in!

IsaacSales Associate.

Issac is a student in Lakewood and loves all ball sports. Isaac is a football coach along with picking up side jobs coaching little ones. Isaac can help you with anything basketball, football, and baseball!

MaxSales Associate.

Max is a recent graduate from Evergreen planning to attend CSU. Max is a local Eagle Scout and has a wide variety of knowledge over everything we carry! If you have general questions, or just need a good sports conversation, Max is your man!